Start with the output, then choose the input
Write one concrete requirement: “Every Friday, the coordinator needs approved minutes by person and project.” That requirement does not, by itself, call for screenshots or a history of websites. Separate duration, attendance, task allocation and device activity: they answer different questions. Ask contributors how work actually happens, including meetings and work away from a computer, before selecting a collection method.
Compare the work each method creates
A manual timesheet shifts effort to recall and timely entry. A start/stop timer shifts effort to remembering transitions. Automatic capture shifts effort to interpreting and correcting recorded activity. DeskTime documents manual options alongside automatic tracking; Clockify documents a manual timesheet view. Those features are examples, not evidence that either will fit your team.
Scroll horizontally to compare every column.
| Method | Pilot case | Failure to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Manual entry | Record a meeting before the day ends | Reconstructed durations with no explanation |
| Start/stop timer | Switch tasks twice and take a break | Timer left running on the wrong task |
| Automatic capture | Include a call away from the keyboard | Activity gaps interpreted as no work |
Use one fictional day to compare methods
Try a 45-minute task, a 20-minute call and a 15-minute task change. Record expected durations before evaluating a tool. Check whether the method can explain the 80-minute total and preserve the project assignment. Count the number of corrections and the time needed to review them. This is a proposed pilot; do not enter another person’s actual activity without resolving collection authority.
Keep a simpler method when it passes
If a shared sheet supplies the required fields, corrections are understandable and review takes manageable effort, a subscription may solve no demonstrated problem. Conversely, if repeated missing entries or permission conflicts survive a clearly explained process, test software against those specific failures. Decide from complete records and workable participation, not a vendor’s productivity percentage.
Sources and boundaries
These pages were read on 2026-09-23. Primary documentation supports the dated product facts. Proposed checks and fictional examples are our editorial method.
- DeskTime — manual — Vendor product page · desktime.com · checked 2026-09-23
- Clockify — timesheet — Vendor product page · clockify.me · checked 2026-09-23